Login
Should Everyone Be Wearing a Health Tracker Now?
Fitness trackers and wearable health technology, like your Whoop, Oura Ring, FitBit, and AppleWatch, used to be a flex for gym rats and techies. Now they’re nudging their way into primary care, remote monitoring programs, insurance incentives, and yes, even your grandma’s wrist. With the promise of continuous data on heart rate, sleep, stress, glucose, and more, wearable tech is being positioned as a healthcare game changer.
But as we tiptoe (or tumble) into an era of universal adoption, the real question isn’t just can these devices transform care, it’s for whom? And at what cost?
Let’s break it down.
The Benefits of Wearable Health Technology (When They Work as Intended)
1. Your Body’s Personal Hype Team
Today’s wearables and fitness devices aren’t just glorified pedometers. They’re 24/7 biometric detectives that can flag early signs of arrhythmia (irregular heart beat), oxygen dips, or sleep apnea before your body sends up a flare. Think of them as your health’s backstage crew quietly catching issues before they steal the spotlight.
2. Motivation in a (Tiny) Wristband
Studies show people using remote health monitoring tools and fitness wearables take an average of 1,300 extra steps a day and improve their sleep hygiene (Ferguson, Ty et al. 2022). Real-time nudges like “Time to stand!” may seem annoying, but they work. (Unless you’re in the middle of your kid’s violin recital. Then they’re just rude.)
3. Tailored Insights = Smarter Self-Care
Whether you’re managing diabetes, hypertension, or plain old burnout, personalized feedback helps people track trends and course-correct faster. That’s a big leap from “just lose weight and walk more.” People are getting health insights tailored to them in real time. Fitness wearables offer a personalized feedback loop and customized recommendations on your health and activity.
4. More Than a Snapshot for Your Doctor
Your annual physical provides… what, 12 minutes of interaction and a blood draw? Wearables give providers long term data over time, and right now. That context can dramatically improve clinical decision-making (assuming, of course, your provider actually sees the data but more on that later).
5. SOS Mode, Activated
Some wearable health devices now detect irregular heart rhythms, falls, or blood sugar crashes and can ping your emergency contact or even 911. That’s not futuristic, it’s lifesaving. Especially for older adults or those managing multiple chronic conditions.
6. Potential for Lower Healthcare Costs
Theoretically, better prevention = fewer ER visits and expensive interventions. That’s good news for both patients and overburdened healthcare systems. But the key word here is potential. The savings aren’t automatic or evenly distributed.
Risks and Concerns with Wearable Health Devices
1. Privacy? Not So Fast.
Here’s the thing, most health devices and fitness wearables are not covered by HIPAA. That means your heart rate, sleep cycles, menstrual cycles and mood metrics could be sold to third parties. Creepy? Yes. Common? Also, YES.
And don’t forget cloud breaches. We’ve already seen fitness apps leak user locations and health info. The more data you wear, the more vulnerable you may be.
2. False Positives, False Hope
Not all devices are created equal. Some aren’t FDA-cleared, and even among the good ones, false alarms happen. Over-relying on gadgetry can lead to either unnecessary panic or dangerous complacency.
3. Tech Fatigue is Real
There’s a thin line between self-tracking and self-obsessing. For some users, wearable data becomes another source of stress: “I only slept for five hours and my stress score is high and now I’m stressed about being stressed.”
4. Are We Empowering or Policing?
Here’s where things get ethically murky. What happens if employers, insurers, or public programs start requiring wearables to qualify for benefits or coverage tiers? We risk shifting from choice to compliance. Surveillance by any other name still smells… a little dystopian.
What Research Says About Wearables in Healthcare (and What It Doesn’t)
There’s early evidence that wearables can improve outcomes:
- A South Korean study showed up to 61% improvement in metabolic syndrome markers with wearables or smartphone trackers (Joung, et al., 2025).
- Glucose monitors help patients stay within target ranges, reducing complications.
- Some cardiac programs are now using remote monitoring to reduce hospital readmissions.
But let’s be honest: most studies are observational, self-reported, or funded by companies with skin in the game. We need more large-scale, independent trials to say definitively that wearables are clinically and cost-effectively making a difference.
Who’s Getting Left Behind?
1. Cost is Still a Barrier
Most insurance plans don’t cover wearables, and the devices themselves can run from $100 to $500+. Add a subscription for analytics or advanced features, and it’s easy to see why uptake is skewed toward the affluent.
2. Digital Literacy Matters
If you’ve ever helped a parent pair Bluetooth headphones, you already know, tech can be confusing. Many seniors, people with disabilities, or those who speak limited English may struggle to use these tools effectively, or at all.
3. The System Isn’t Ready
Even among users who want to share their health data with their doctor, fewer than 1 in 4 actually do. Why? Because most clinics don’t have a standardized way to receive or interpret it. That’s a workflow problem, not a tech one and unfortunately, it keeps the full potential of wearables locked in a data silo.
The Future of Wearable Health Technology
Wearables are no longer just cool accessories, they’re becoming integral to how we track, understand, and respond to health. But their promise is only as good as the infrastructure and policies we build around them.
Without equity safeguards, we risk deepening disparities and digital redlining in a world already fractured by health injustice. Without privacy protections, we risk turning bodies into barcodes for corporate profit. Without provider integration, we risk flooding our systems with data that no one knows how to use.
In short: the tech is exciting. The consequences are real. And the decisions we make now, about access, safety, and inclusivity, will define whether this revolution uplifts everyone or leaves too many behind.
References
Ferguson, Ty et al. (2022) Effectiveness of wearable activity trackers to increase physical activity and improve health: a systematic review of systematic reviews and meta-analyses. The Lancet Digital Health, Volume 4, Issue 8. E615-E626.
Joung, Kyung-In, Sook Hee An, Joon Seok Bang, and Kwang Joon Kim. (2025) “Comparative Effectiveness of Wearable Devices and Built-In Step Counters in Reducing Metabolic Syndrome Risk in South Korea: Population-Based Cohort Study.” JMIR mHealth and uHealth 13 (14). https://doi.org/10.2196/64527.